Roth vs Traditional IRA Calculator 2026
Roth and traditional IRAs hold the same money and grow the same way. The only difference is when the tax is paid. Enter your rates to see which one leaves more after tax.
The short answer: compare your tax rate now with your rate in retirement. When they match, the two tie. When your retirement rate is lower, the traditional IRA wins. When it is higher, the Roth wins. On $10,000 a year for 30 years at 6%, 22% now and 12% later, the traditional IRA wins by $79,058.19.
- Roth IRA after tax
- Traditional IRA before tax
- Traditional IRA tax paid
- Traditional IRA after tax
- Winner
- Difference
The one rule
Put the same pre-tax dollars in both. The Roth contribution is made after tax, so $10,000 pre-tax at 22% becomes $7,800 in the Roth. The traditional contribution goes in whole at $10,000. Both grow at the same rate.
The Roth comes out tax-free. The traditional is taxed on withdrawal. When the two rates are equal, the multiplication is commutative: the after-tax results are identical. The whole decision is a bet on which rate is higher.
Worked example
A saver puts $10,000 a year of pre-tax money aside for 30 years at 6%. At 22% now and 22% later, the Roth holds $616,653.85 after tax and the traditional holds $790,581.86 before tax and $616,653.85 after tax: a tie. At 22% now and 12% later, the traditional holds $695,712.04 after tax and wins by $79,058.19. At 22% now and 32% later, the Roth would win by the same logic in reverse.
What the rate bet depends on
Your retirement rate depends on your income then, not now. A saver whose income will fall in retirement, for example after leaving a high-paying job, usually faces a lower rate later and does better in a traditional IRA. A young saver in a low bracket now, or anyone expecting higher income, pensions, and RMDs later, usually does better in a Roth. Tax law itself can move rates either way, which is a reason some savers hold both and split contributions between them.
What this calculator excludes
- Contribution limits. The IRA limit of $7,500 ($8,600 at 50 or older) covers both IRAs together. The comparison uses the amount you enter, which may exceed what you can actually contribute.
- RMDs. The traditional IRA forces withdrawals from age 73 or 75, which can push up the retirement tax rate. The Roth has no RMDs for the owner. The calculator compares balances, not the RMD path.
- The five-year rule and penalties. Roth earnings need five years and age 59 and a half to come out tax-free. Early traditional withdrawals usually mean tax plus a 10% penalty.
Related pages
Sources
- IRS Notice 2025-67: 2026 IRA limit of $7,500, catch-up of $1,100, and the Roth phase-out ranges.
- IRS Publication 590-A: Roth and traditional IRA rules, the five-year rule, and qualified distributions at 59 and a half.
- IRC 408 and 408A: traditional and Roth IRA rules.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a Roth or traditional IRA better?
- It comes down to your tax rate now against your tax rate in retirement. When the rates match, the after-tax results are equal. When your rate in retirement will be lower, the traditional IRA wins. When it will be higher, the Roth wins. The calculator above runs both on your rates.
- Is Roth or traditional better at 22%?
- It depends on the retirement rate, not the current one alone. At 22% now and 22% later, the two tie. At 22% now and 12% later, the traditional IRA wins by about $79,058 on $10,000 a year for 30 years at 6%. At 22% now and 32% later, the Roth wins by the same logic in reverse.
- Can I have both a Roth and a traditional IRA?
- Yes. The $7,500 limit ($8,600 at 50 or older) covers both together, so splitting the money between them uses the same limit. Many savers hold both and choose each year's split by their tax rate that year.
- Does the Roth vs traditional choice work the same for a 401(k)?
- Yes, the math is the same: Roth 401(k) contributions are after tax and come out tax-free, traditional 401(k) contributions are pre-tax and taxed on withdrawal. The 401(k) limit is higher, $24,500 for 2026, plus an $8,000 catch-up at 50 or older.
Figures last verified: November 17, 2026. Estimates only, not tax advice.